In the ball the integrand is non-negative so J ≥ 0; in the ball a steeply oscillating small y makes J negative.
Counterexample bank
Part C is won by knowing which tempting claims are false. 148 counterexamples; 85 free. The rest come with the Notes pack.
AllODEPDEabeliananalyticityanovabairecalculus of variationscanonical formscauchy-riemanncompactnesscompletenesscomplexconformalconnectednesscontinuitycontour integrationconvergencedifferentiationdistributionsfieldsfixed pointgaloisgreengroupsharmonicinjectivityintegral equationsintegrationlaurentlimsuplinear algebraliouvillelpmarkovmeasuremechanicsmetric spacesmultivariablemultivariatenumericalp-groupspermutationspolynomialspower seriesprobabilityquadratic formsreal analysisregressionresiduesringssamplingseparabilityseparationsequencesseriessingularitiesstabilitystatisticssylowtestingtopologyuniform convergencewronskianzeros
#1 · ODE, PDE & Applied Mathematics › Calculus of Variations
“A weak minimum of a functional is a strong minimum” — false
Counterexample: J[y] = ∫₀^π (1 − (y′)²)y² dx at y ≡ 0
calculus of variations