NETMaths
The bookUnit 2 · Groups38 / 83

Subgroups, cosets, Lagrange, cyclic groups

Why this is asked: Lagrange gives one direction only. The exam tests the failures: no subgroup of a given order (A₄), and 'union of proper subgroups ⇔ not cyclic'.

Lagrange and its partial converses

|H| divides |G|, and o(g) divides |G|, so gGg^{|G|} = e.

Statement True?
d | |G| ⇒ G has a subgroup of order d ✗ — A4A_{4} has order 12, no subgroup of order 6
p prime, p | |G| ⇒ G has an element of order p ✓ Cauchy
pᵏ | |G| ⇒ G has a subgroup of order pᵏ ✓ Sylow
G abelian and d | |G| ⇒ subgroup of order d
G cyclic ⇒ exactly one subgroup of each order dividing |G|

Cyclic groups

Zn\mathbb{Z}_{n} has φ(d)\varphi(d) elements of order d for each d | n, and exactly one subgroup of each such order. |Aut(Zn)(\mathbb{Z}_{n})| =φ(n)= \varphi(n).

Union of proper subgroups: a finite group is the union of its proper subgroups iff it is not cyclic — a generator lies in no proper subgroup, and conversely every element generates a proper one. No group over any field is the union of two proper subgroups.

Order arithmetic

  • o(ab) = o(a)o(b) when a, b commute and gcd(o(a), o(b)) = 1. Without commuting it can be infinite: in GL2_{2} two elements of order 2 can multiply to infinite order.
  • Index 2 ⇒ normal. Index p (smallest prime dividing |G|) ⇒ normal.
  • |G| = p ⇒ cyclic. |G| =p2= p^{2} \Rightarrow abelian (Zp2(\mathbb{Z}_{p^{2}} or Zp×Zp)\mathbb{Z}_p \times \mathbb{Z}_p), not necessarily cyclic.
  • |G| = pq with p < q and p ∤ q − 1 ⇒ cyclic.

Key takeaways

  • Converse of Lagrange fails (A4(A_{4}, order 6); Cauchy and Sylow are the true partial converses.
  • Non-cyclic ⇔ union of proper subgroups. p2- p^{2} \Rightarrow abelian, but not necessarily cyclic.

See it move

Lagrange's theorem and its false converseinteractive

Order divides — but a divisor need not give a subgroup, and A₄ is the reason.

Unlock interactive visuals

The trap here

“If d divides |G| then G has a subgroup of order d” — false

A4A_{4} has order 12 but no subgroup of order 6

More on this →

Check yourself

Let G be any finite group. Which one of the following is necessarily true?

Next: Normal subgroups, quotients, isomorphism theorems

Create a free account to keep your place and have this feed your study plan.

Open this in the full syllabus view · Unit 2