Skip to content
Part CCSIR NET December 2023types-of-discontinuity

Types of discontinuity

Which of the following statements are true?

  1. A.f(x) = [x] sin(1/x) for x ≠ 0, f(0) = 0 (where [x] is the integer part) has a discontinuity at 0 which is removable.
  2. B. for x ≠ 0, f(0) = 0, has a discontinuity at 0 which is NOT removable.
  3. C.f(x) = for x < 0, f(x) = for x ≥ 0, has a jump discontinuity at 0.
  4. D.If are of bounded variation, then fg has at most countably many discontinuities.

The idea, in plain words

A break in a graph can be repaired only if the function heads towards a single value from both sides. Check each one from the left and from the right separately: some settle on two different values, and some never settle at all because they oscillate faster and faster.

Solution

(1) As x → 0⁻, [x] = −1 and −sin(1/x) oscillates: no left limit, not removable. (2) sin(log x) oscillates as x → 0⁺. (3) Left limit 0, right limit e. (4) A product of BV functions is BV, and BV functions have only countably many (jump) discontinuities.

Why each option is right or wrong

Checked against 2 symbolic computations
  • A.WrongBoundary and endpoint

    False. Check both sides, because [x] jumps at 0. For 0 < x < 1 the integer part is 0, so f ≡ 0 on the right and the right limit is 0 — which is where most students stop. For −1 ≤ x < 0 the integer part is −1, so f(x) = −sin(1/x), which oscillates without limit as x → 0⁻. A removable discontinuity needs the two-sided limit to exist; here the left limit does not. The mistake: evaluating the side on which the floor function is harmless and never checking the other.

  • B.Correct

    True. As x → 0⁺, , so sin(log x) oscillates through [−1, 1] forever and no limit exists. A discontinuity is removable only when the limit exists but disagrees with the assigned value; here there is nothing to remove.

  • C.Correct

    True, and it is a genuine jump because both one-sided limits exist and differ. From the left, so e^(1/x) → 0 (SymPy samples e^(1/t) down to t = −0.05 and reaches 2×10⁻. From the right, . Left limit 0, right limit e.

  • D.Correct

    True. A product of two functions of bounded variation is again of bounded variation on [0,1] (each is a difference of monotone functions, and BV is closed under products of bounded functions). A BV function has only jump discontinuities and at most countably many of them.

1 of these 1 wrong options correspond to a named reasoning error — the same errors recur across subjects.

Related counterexample: Continuous on a bounded interval ⇒ bounded

More on this topic

The chapter behind this: Continuity vs uniform continuity vs Lipschitz — free to read

From Continuity and DifferentiationContinuity, uniform continuity, Lipschitz

ShareWhatsAppTelegram